El derecho policial dentro del sistema de derecho administrativo. La necesidad de reconciliar la relación.

Contenido principal del artículo

Olha Ihorivna Bezpalova
Tatiana Anatoliivna Kobzieva
Volodymyr Valeriiovych Korniienko
Ivan Vasylovych Kritsak

Detalles del artículo

Olha Ihorivna Bezpalova, , Honored Science and Technology Figure of Ukraine, Head of the Department of Police Activity and Public Administration of the Faculty No. 3, Kharkiv National University of Internal Affairs

Doctor of Jurisprudence, Professor, Honored Science and Technology Figure of Ukraine, Head of the Department of Police Activity and Public Administration of the Faculty No. 3, Kharkiv National University of Internal Affairs. orcid: https://orcid.org/0000-0003-2886-695X

Tatiana Anatoliivna Kobzieva , Doctor of Legal Science, Associate Professor, Department of Administrative, Economic Law and Financial Economic Security, Academic and Research Institute of Law, Sumy State University

Doctor of Legal Science, Associate Professor, Department of Administrative, Economic Law and Financial Economic Security, Academic and Research Institute of Law, Sumy State University. orcid: https://orcid.org/0000-0001-6176-0239

Volodymyr Valeriiovych Korniienko , Associate Professor of the Department of Police Activity and Public Administration of the Faculty No. 3, Kharkiv National University of Internal Affairs

Candidate of Juridical Science, Senior Researcher, Associate Professor of the Department of Police Activity and Public Administration of the Faculty No. 3, Kharkiv National University of Internal Affairs. orcid: http://https://orcid.org/0000-0001-7338-0794

Ivan Vasylovych Kritsak, Doctoral Candidate of Legal Science, Assistant of the Head of the Main Department of the National Police in Ivano-Frankivsk region.

Doctoral Candidate of Legal Science, Assistant of the Head of the Main Department of the National Police in Ivano-Frankivsk region. orcid: https://orcid.org/0000-0003-3530-4269

Sección
Artículo de investigación

Resumen

Las cuestiones relativas al control y la participación de la policía son de gran importancia cuando se ponen de manifiesto aspectos del derecho administrativo. Se trata de que no hay forma o instancias en las que se pueda garantizar la protección legítima de los derechos y libertades individuales sin la presencia de la policía para garantizar la protección de los derechos mediante el respeto del Estado de Derecho. La única forma de mantener esta protección es mediante el funcionamiento o la aplicación del derecho administrativo. Al tratar el concepto de derecho policial, se hace hincapié en las responsabilidades que tienen estas fuerzas del orden cuando se trata de asuntos relacionados con la seguridad del Estado, la protección de los individuos que viven en una sociedad determinada y, en cierta medida, de todo el público. No cabe duda de que la función de la policía es mantener la paz y la seguridad dentro de una sociedad determinada, pero la cuestión que deberíamos plantearnos es si las funciones que desempeñan se realizan dentro de los límites del respeto a los derechos humanos fundamentales, siguiendo el debido proceso de la ley que es la base o esencia fundamental e imperativa del derecho administrativo. Una cosa es garantizar la seguridad, y la otra es garantizar que al hacer cumplir esta seguridad, las libertades y derechos fundamentales de las personas sean respetados por los supuestos llamados agentes de la ley. Por lo tanto, desde este punto de vista se puede decir, sin ningún tipo de cuestionamiento, que en ningún caso el derecho policial debe funcionar sin la intervención del derecho administrativo, ambos se complementan mutuamente, y las actividades de la policía deben realizarse en estricto respeto y cumplimiento del derecho administrativo.

Artem Solomakha. Retrospective and Perspectives of Police Law in Ukraine. ADMINISTRATIVE LAW AND PROCEDURE 11. 2015.
I. I. Mushket. THE GENESIS OF “POLICE LAW” IN THE CONTEXT OF THE EVOLUTION OF LEGAL SYSTEM: HISTORICAL AND THEORETICAL ANALYSIS. Doctoral Thesis, Nizhny Novgorod Academy. (2003). Pg. 26-55.
I. S. Grytsenko. The Main Trends of the Historical Development of the Doctrine about the System of Administrative Law (from the Policial to the Administrative one). SCIENTIFIC BULLETIN OF LVIV STATE UNIVERSITY OF INTERNAL AFFAIRS 2. 2008. Available at: https://www.lvduvs.edu.ua/documents_pdf/visnyky/nvsy/02_2008/08gispda.pdf
K. S. Bielskyi. On the System of Administrative Law. STATE AND LAW 3. 1998.
M. Babšek, N. Tomaževič & P. Kovač. (2020). Administrative Reforms and the Rule of Law: Case-Law Analysis as an Inspiration for the Slovene Reorganisation of Social Work Centres. CROATIAN AND COMPARATIVE PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION 4. 2020. Pg. 595-622.
M. I. Biiushkina. Formation of the Science of Police Law (XVII Century-80s of the XIX Century). ACADEMIC BULLETIN 14. 2011. Pg. 11-14.
M. N. Kurko, P. D. Bilenchuk & A. A. Yarmoliuk. The Science of Police Law in Ukrainian State Building: Origins, Milestones, Historiography, Current State and Ways of Priority Development. OUR LAW 4. 2015.
O. S. Pronevych. Organizational and Legal Grounds of Police (Militia) of Germany, Poland and Ukraine: A Comparative Legal Analysis. Thesis for a Doctor’s Degree by Specialty 12.00.07. Administrative Law and Procedure; Financial Law; Informational Law. Kharkiv National University of Internal Affairs. (2011). Pg. 22-28.
P. D. Bilenchuk. Conceptual Principles of Providing Criminal Justice by the Latest Means of Cognition. VICHE 12. 2013. Pg. 5-7.
P. D. Bilenchuk. TRAINING OF LAWYERS OF THE NEW GENERATION IN THE XXI CENTURY: WORLD EXPERIENCE AND REALITIES OF THE UKRAINIAN CLASSICAL UNIVERSITY. Dakor Publishing House. (2014).
P. D. Bilenchuk & A. A. Yarmoliuk. STRATEGY FOR THE DEVELOPMENT OF FORENSIC SCIENCE IN THE THIRD MILLENNIUM. FORENSIC ACTIVITY: CURRENT STATUS AND PERSPECTIVES OF THE DEVELOPMENT. National Academy of Internal Affairs. (2015).
Rudi Antariksawan & Muhammad Mustofa. The Direction of Police Community Policy in the Prevention of Traffic Accidents in Polda Metro Jaya. JURNAL CITA HUKUM (INDONESIAN LAW JOURNAL) 1. 2020. Pg. 17-32. https://doi.org/10.15408/jch.v8i1.13762
R. V. Kutuzov. Teoretical-Methodological Principles of Science of Police (Administrative) Law in Explaining of Ukrainian Scientists Second Half of ХІХ — Beginning of ХХ of Century. V. O. SUKHOMLYNSKYI NATIONAL UNIVERSITY OF MYKOLAIV 2. 2014. Pp. 8-12.
Y. Fomin. Police Law and Police Legislation as a Legal Basis of Internal Affairs Agencies’ Activity. LAW AND SAFETY 41. 2011. Pg. 90-95.
Y. S. Shemshuchenko et al. (Eds.). Anthology of Ukrainian Legal Thought. POLICE AND ADMINISTRATIVE LAW. Yurydychna Knyha. (2003).